Why progressive nationalism is losing out to an aggressive kind
Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • COVID-19
    • Bangladesh
    • Splash
    • Videos
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Infograph
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Thoughts
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Archive
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
    • Supplement
  • বাংলা
The Business Standard

Friday
August 12, 2022

Sign In
Subscribe
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • COVID-19
    • Bangladesh
    • Splash
    • Videos
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Infograph
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Thoughts
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Archive
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
    • Supplement
  • বাংলা
FRIDAY, AUGUST 12, 2022
Why progressive nationalism is losing out to an aggressive kind

Thoughts

Anush Kapadia
14 February, 2020, 12:45 pm
Last modified: 14 February, 2020, 12:50 pm

Related News

  • BNP will occupy the streets in 10 days, say leaders
  • 7 political parties form new alliance
  • JaPa announces 2-day protest programme condemning fuel price hike 
  • Around 400 sued over BNP men-police clash in Bhola
  • Can regulatory decisions mend an economic crisis that has political dimensions?  

Why progressive nationalism is losing out to an aggressive kind

The failure of liberal idealists to grasp ground realities has made space for exclusivist forms of an attractive idea

Anush Kapadia
14 February, 2020, 12:45 pm
Last modified: 14 February, 2020, 12:50 pm
Right-wing nationalism is on the rise in India. Photo: Reuters
Right-wing nationalism is on the rise in India. Photo: Reuters

Politics is a game of scale that calls for the creation of alliances, and alliances made up of diverse constituents need powerful narratives to hold them together. Whence the structural significance of nationalism, a narrative whose binding properties operate at terrifying scale to clear the field of competing narratives with less pull on hearts and minds. The rise of hard right populist nationalisms in various parts of the world, including India, sets the progressives of the world a tough challenge. What is their counter narrative?

Progressives tend to eschew nationalism in favour of liberalism or ideas further to the left, all of which have substantial internationalist credentials. Progressives both left and liberal take nationalism to be essentially exclusionary, a modern rendition of ancient tribal loyalties that we ought to shed if we are to enable respect for individuals and grant them space to flourish.

Arguably, the rise of right-wing nationalism has been aided by the dismissiveness with which progressives treat nationalism. The right has basically had the powerful nationalist narrative all to itself. This is not just political folly, but historical irony.

All nationalisms are not right-wing in orientation. Our own anti-imperial nationalism shared with most postcolonial nationalisms a progressive agenda for social change. Batting for the nation against the empire could and did mean a tactical and temporary suppression of internal hierarchies, such as those of caste and patriarchy, but the broad orientation was clearly progressive.

Nations come in two types: ethnic nations of the blood-and-soil type, and civic nations based on republican ideas of a social contract. The substantial overlap between the two in the birthplace of modern nationalism, 18th century Europe, means that we often forget the republican essence of modern nation states. This version of nationalism sees people come together not merely because of an often-invented shared history or culture, but because of a shared belief in the future. The people of civic nations share nothing except a belief in certain principles of how collective life ought to be organized.

This is why our Constitution is so much more than a set of rules. In an empire-nation, all we have in common is our principles set down in the common rulebook. The Constitution defines the nation and clearly makes us a civic rather than an ethnic nation.

All nations carry the conceit that they are special, but Indian nationalism is really sui generis. We do not have a standard nationalism because we do not have a standard nation: India is not France. "Unity in diversity" outlines a vision of nationalism that is entirely different from the 18th/19th century European model that ironically seems to be the inspiration for the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). We chose to make a nation out of a sprawling continental empire, so we had to think out of the European box. The sheer novelty of that vision is something to celebrate.

There are good political reasons for progressives to worry. Invoking nationalism leaves them open to attack from the right. However, that political risk simply means being mindful of and guarding that flank, rather than abandoning nationalism altogether. A large part of what is driving the national protests against the new citizenship law is precisely this question. What kind of nationalism do we want to define India?

If a progressive nationalism doesn't show up, the right will win without a ball being bowled.

Nations are usually born in the violence of exclusion. However, the nation-state remains a brute political fact. For all our global integration, the state remains indispensable. As such, the rise of right-wing nationalism actually contains a kernel of truth—the dire need to rebalance a global system that has stretched integration too far.

Not only does globalization in its current form threaten local identities and fuel inequality, global supply chains emit massive amounts of carbon. A recent study published by America's National Academy of Sciences noted that "37% of global emissions are from fossil fuels traded internationally and an additional 6.4 billion tons CO2 or 23% of global emissions are embodied in traded goods." Far from the utopia of comparative advantage, global trade appears to be boiling the planet. The global economy needs to be scaled back to local and national geographies if we are to survive as a species.

Working people give voice to their concerns with inequality and diminished life chances in the only language on offer, that of exclusionary nationalism. The liberal sneer only hardens their resolve. Yet the desire to bring jobs back home runs with and not against the fundamental needs of the planet because it truncates carbon-spewing global supply chains. Economic nationalism is good for the planet, but the only flavour on offer is an exclusionary one.

It is a truism in social science that all people crave a sense of belonging to something larger than themselves. If progressives don't forge inclusive ideas of belonging, the right will. The choice cannot be between the current version of globalization underwritten by a utopian liberal internationalism and a closed world of competing right-wing nationalisms. Even if we have serious and justified doubts about nationalism, tactically we have little choice but to fight for a progressive, inclusive form of nationalism that sponsors a sustainable scaling of our global economy.

Luckily for us in India, we have such a nationalism ready at hand. It is Tagore's nationalism, rooted yet open to the world, and it is currently on the march nationwide.

Anush Kapadia is faculty member at the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay in the humanities and social sciences department.

politics

Comments

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderation decisions are subjective. Published comments are readers’ own views and The Business Standard does not endorse any of the readers’ comments.

Top Stories

  • Life’s a beach.Photographer: Christopher Pike/Bloomberg
    Over New York, London and Hong Kong? Time to move on
  • Defrauding subscribers, ringID invested Tk33cr in stocks, finds CID
    Defrauding subscribers, ringID invested Tk33cr in stocks, finds CID
  • Photo: TBS
    People in Bangladesh are living in heaven amid global recession: Momen

MOST VIEWED

  • Can a country go bankrupt?
    Can a country go bankrupt?
  • Are we fighting a losing climate battle?
    Are we fighting a losing climate battle?
  • Therese Raphael. Sketch: TBS
    Why British conservatives went cold on Rishi Sunak
  • Rakib Al Hasan. Sketch: TBS
    The overlooked link between foreign currency reserve crisis and money laundering
  • Why superpower crises are a good thing
    Why superpower crises are a good thing
  • Pharma companies: A safe haven for investors in this bear market
    Pharma companies: A safe haven for investors in this bear market

Related News

  • BNP will occupy the streets in 10 days, say leaders
  • 7 political parties form new alliance
  • JaPa announces 2-day protest programme condemning fuel price hike 
  • Around 400 sued over BNP men-police clash in Bhola
  • Can regulatory decisions mend an economic crisis that has political dimensions?  

Features

Some species of mantises resemble flowers, with just one exception — they hunt. Photo: Collected

Mantis memoir: A master predator

10h | Earth
Bye bye! Photographer: Michael Zarrilli/Getty Images North America via Bloomberg

Three major takeaways from the FBI search on Trump’s home

1d | Panorama
Photo: Noor A Alam/TBS

Big dreams in small rooms: The aspiring nurses of Geneva Camp

1d | Panorama
Illustration: TBS

How to deal with toxic people at work

1d | Pursuit

More Videos from TBS

The ship that was sunk to kill a journalist

The ship that was sunk to kill a journalist

2h | Videos
What's next after searching Trump's house

What's next after searching Trump's house

11h | Videos
Dollar rate increasing in open market despite various initiatives by central bank

Dollar rate increasing in open market despite various initiatives by central bank

11h | Videos
Salimullah Khan on Joddopi Amar Guru

Salimullah Khan on Joddopi Amar Guru

11h | Videos

Most Read

1
Dollar crisis: BB orders removal of 6 banks’ treasury chiefs 
Banking

Dollar crisis: BB orders removal of 6 banks’ treasury chiefs 

2
Diesel price hiked by Tk34 per litre, Octane by Tk46
Energy

Diesel price hiked by Tk34 per litre, Octane by Tk46

3
Photo: Collected
Transport

Will Tokyo’s traffic model solve Dhaka’s gridlocks?

4
Arrest warrant against Habib Group chairman, 4 others 
Crime

Arrest warrant against Habib Group chairman, 4 others 

5
File Photo: State Minister for Power, Energy and Mineral Resources Nasrul Hamid
Energy

All factories to remain closed once a week under rationing system

6
Anwar Group looks beyond slowdown – invests Tk5,000cr
Economy

Anwar Group looks beyond slowdown – invests Tk5,000cr

EMAIL US
[email protected]
FOLLOW US
WHATSAPP
+880 1847416158
The Business Standard
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
Copyright © 2022
The Business Standard All rights reserved
Technical Partner: RSI Lab

Contact Us

The Business Standard

Main Office -4/A, Eskaton Garden, Dhaka- 1000

Phone: +8801847 416158 - 59

Send Opinion articles to - [email protected]

For advertisement- [email protected]