How to build a great firewall with Indian characteristics
Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Splash
  • Features
  • Videos
  • Long Read
  • Games
  • Epaper
  • More
    • COVID-19
    • Bangladesh
    • Infograph
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Thoughts
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Subscribe
    • Archive
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
    • Supplement
  • বাংলা
The Business Standard
FRIDAY, MAY 20, 2022
FRIDAY, MAY 20, 2022
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Splash
  • Features
  • Videos
  • Long Read
  • Games
  • Epaper
  • More
    • COVID-19
    • Bangladesh
    • Infograph
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Thoughts
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Subscribe
    • Archive
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
    • Supplement
  • বাংলা
How to build a great firewall with Indian characteristics

Panorama

Tim Culpan & Andy Mukherjee, Bloomberg
01 June, 2021, 01:00 pm
Last modified: 01 June, 2021, 01:03 pm

Related News

  • India's power grid creaks under hybrid work model, heatwave
  • JPMorgan downgrades India's IT sector as Covid boom fades
  • India retains top spot as fastest-growing economy: UN
  • Sundarban tigers travelling to West Bengal in search of mates
  • US to offer India $500 mn in military aid to reduce Russia dependence: Report

How to build a great firewall with Indian characteristics

Brick by brick, the curbs around India’s internet are being built. Some companies are fighting back; others may join the construction

Tim Culpan & Andy Mukherjee, Bloomberg
01 June, 2021, 01:00 pm
Last modified: 01 June, 2021, 01:03 pm
Free and open or stymied and controlled. Photo: Dhiraj Singh via Bloomberg
Free and open or stymied and controlled. Photo: Dhiraj Singh via Bloomberg

India's internet future — free and open, or stymied and controlled — may be decided by a 224-page lawsuit filed by WhatsApp last week.

Saying that it wanted to curb fake news, revenge porn and other ills, Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government introduced new rules in February that would compel social media platforms such as Facebook Inc.'s WhatsApp to trace chat messages, among other things.

As the three-month deadline for compliance ended, WhatsApp filed its petition in the Delhi High Court. The U.S. company is arguing that being asked to track the originator of a message has no legal sanction. It doesn't protect people such as journalists and political activists from arbitrary state action. Nor does the rule meet the proportionality test — required now by Indian law following a 2017 Supreme Court verdict — of being the least restrictive infringement of Indians' fundamental right to privacy. 

WhatsApp contends that keeping a log of messages would require it to break end-to-end encryption and save billions of messages sent by its more than 500 million users in India.

How the case is decided in the coming year or so as it winds its way to a verdict followed by an inevitable appeal may come down to the technical details of data transmission. Internet messages consist of two parts: the header and the payload. That unencrypted header, which can be read by any router it passes through, can be thought of as an envelope that shows identifying information, such as originating and destination IP addresses. The payload is the message itself. If it's unencrypted, anyone can read it along the way. If it's encrypted, then the message is scrambled using hard-to-crack algorithms.

The government says that fingerprinting each and every message — making it traceable — doesn't include the content. But WhatsApp pleads that it will still undermine E2E encryption, posing a serious risk to privacy, and would open up WhatsApp (and other chat apps like Signal) not only to government interference, but also to hacking attacks. 

The rules require significant social media intermediaries to appoint a compliance officer, a grievance officer and a 24/7 contact person, something they're grudgingly accepting. Facebook itself has fallen in line. Alphabet Inc. and its Google unit "always respect local laws in every country," Chief Executive Officer Sundar Pichai said, according to India's Economic Times. Twitter Inc. has asked for a three-month extension.

But traceability is a bigger battle, and WhatsApp was prepared for it. As the news website The Morning Context noted, India's digital intermediary rules look a lot like those passed by Brazil's Senate in June last year. That bill, PLS 2630/2020, more commonly known as the Fake News law, required companies to store "massively forwarded" messages, with the complete chain of communication, for three months. The Indian version doesn't stipulate a holding period, nor is it restricted to messages going viral. Even if the payload stays encrypted, enormous, forever archives would be of limited use. Simply taking a screenshot or copy-pasting a message would start the chain from scratch.

The bigger concern for India is not that the Modi government is taking a leaf from Brazil's playbook, but that it's dragging the country backward to the China of 2006. That's when Beijing was powering up The Great Firewall, a mammoth project that would prevent outside information from flowing into the nation and allow authorities to control what was shared internally. The result has been an exit from the world's largest internet market by some of America's biggest names, including Facebook, Google and Twitter.

Those same companies now see India as the next big hope. With plenty of growth ahead, not only for content but also e-commerce and digital payments, none want to be left out.  

Where the People's Republic had the resources to build the firewall itself, and later rely on companies to self-police, India may need domestic business interests to do the job. In the name of a responsible internet and protecting citizens from data imperialists, several will be eager to abet the government in soft censorship. Keeping global tech firms out — or forcing them to accept a subservient role — may help Indian capitalists build their own consumer-centric empires.

New Delhi will be able to ensure that digital communication platforms are popular but docile, amplifying the government's messages without questioning propaganda or exposing state hypocrisy. Long-time China watchers will be familiar. Last week's raid on Twitter's New Delhi and Gurgaon offices, after the service labelled a tweet by a ruling party member as manipulated media, serves as a warning.

Top News

India / WhatsApp

Comments

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderation decisions are subjective. Published comments are readers’ own views and The Business Standard does not endorse any of the readers’ comments.

Top Stories

  • What needs to be done now?
    What needs to be done now?
  • Bangladesh’s currency has lost value by more than Tk7 against the greenback in only around seven days in the kerb market. Photo: Noor-A-Alam
    Dhaka’s kerb market money exchangers losing out on customers
  • A woman walks past the International Monetary Fund (IMF) logo at its headquarters in Washington, US, 10 May 12018. Photo: REUTERS
    IMF urges Asia to be mindful of spillover risks from tightening

MOST VIEWED

  • Bangladesh’s currency has lost value by more than Tk7 against the greenback in only around seven days in the kerb market. Photo: Noor-A-Alam
    Dhaka’s kerb market money exchangers losing out on customers
  • Sketch: TBS
    'Food inflation is an unavoidable consequence of currency devaluation'
  • Illustration: TBS
    ‘Do you have insurance?’: Life of a life insurance agent
  • ‘The geopolitical landscape is undergoing profound change, Dhaka needs to craft proactive strategies’
    ‘The geopolitical landscape is undergoing profound change, Dhaka needs to craft proactive strategies’
  • Graphics: TBS
    Facebook and Bangladeshi politicians: A new tide in mass political communication?
  • Despite Bangladesh having about 24,000 km of waterways, only a few hundred kilometres are covered by commercial launch services. Photo: Saad Abdullah
    Utilising waterways: When common home-goers show the way

Related News

  • India's power grid creaks under hybrid work model, heatwave
  • JPMorgan downgrades India's IT sector as Covid boom fades
  • India retains top spot as fastest-growing economy: UN
  • Sundarban tigers travelling to West Bengal in search of mates
  • US to offer India $500 mn in military aid to reduce Russia dependence: Report

Features

Two paddle steamers (orange coloured) and two new steamers are docked at Badamtoli Rocket Ghat on the bank of the River Buriganga in Old Dhaka. The photo was taken recently. Photo: Mumit M

The last water rockets

48m | Features
Bangladesh’s currency has lost value by more than Tk7 against the greenback in only around seven days in the kerb market. Photo: Noor-A-Alam

Dhaka’s kerb market money exchangers losing out on customers

48m | Panorama
Sketch: TBS

'Food inflation is an unavoidable consequence of currency devaluation'

22h | Interviews
The open-browser-tabs question also tells an interviewer how much of an internet native the job applicant might be. Photo: Noor-a-Alam

The best question to ask a job applicant

22h | Pursuit

More Videos from TBS

Putin's strategies to face Nato

Putin's strategies to face Nato

11h | Videos
How many countries have nuclear weapons and how many are there?

How many countries have nuclear weapons and how many are there?

11h | Videos
Dengue fever is rising, so beware

Dengue fever is rising, so beware

12h | Videos
How a university teacher and PHD holder become farmer

How a university teacher and PHD holder become farmer

16h | Videos

Most Read

1
Tk100 for bike, Tk2,400 for bus to cross Padma Bridge
Bangladesh

Tk100 for bike, Tk2,400 for bus to cross Padma Bridge

2
Representative Photo: Pixabay.
Bangladesh

Microplastics found in 5 local sugar brands

3
Mushfiq Mobarak. Photo: Noor-A-Alam
Panorama

Meet the Yale professor who anchors his research in Bangladesh and scales up interventions globally

4
A packet of US five-dollar bills is inspected at the Bureau of Engraving and Printing in Washington March 26, 2015. REUTERS/Gary Cameron
Banking

Dollar hits Tk100 mark in open market

5
The story of Bangladesh becoming a major bicycle exporter
Industry

The story of Bangladesh becoming a major bicycle exporter

6
PK Halder: How a scamster rose from humble beginnings to a Tk11,000cr empire
Crime

PK Halder: How a scamster rose from humble beginnings to a Tk11,000cr empire

The Business Standard
Top
  • Home
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • About Us
  • Bangladesh
  • International
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Economy
  • Sitemap
  • RSS

Contact Us

The Business Standard

Main Office -4/A, Eskaton Garden, Dhaka- 1000

Phone: +8801847 416158 - 59

Send Opinion articles to - oped.tbs@gmail.com

For advertisement- sales@tbsnews.net

Copyright © 2022 THE BUSINESS STANDARD All rights reserved. Technical Partner: RSI Lab