Kristen Welker has been acclaimed online for her performance as moderator, in particular being praised for keeping candidates to time and not allowing them to talk over her.
She became the second black woman to moderate a presidential debate 28 years after ABC News journalist Carole Simpson became the first in 1992, reports BBC.
The 44-year-old grew up in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and graduated from Harvard in 1998.
Users took social media platforms to encourage the moderator. So far, more than 125,000 tweets have taken over social media about the NBC journalists and co-anchor of NBC show Weekend Today.
Welker would have still been at school when Simpson moderated that debate between Bill Clinton and George HW Bush.
Fox News journalist Chris Wallace faced criticism for his moderation of the last debate between Donald Trump and Joe Biden, while Susan Page was similarly criticised for how she handled the vice-presidential debate between Mike Pence and Kamala Harris.
But clearly Welker was taking notes from those debates, as she was praised specifically for managing to keep the candidates in line, and controlling the conversation - though she did have the advantage of the candidates being muted during each others' allotted two minutes.
Fellow journalists have been vocal in their praise for Welker's performance. NBC's Chief White House Correspondent Hallie Jackson called it "a career-defining moment", while news anchor Harris Faulkner said she "gave the American people a real debate".
And PBS White House Correspondent Yamiche Alcindor said she was "beaming" watching Welker.
MSNBC host Rachel Maddow labelled Welker the "clear winner" of the debate, while previous moderator Chris Wallace told Fox News that he was "jealous" of her - wishing that he had been able to take charge of the debate instead.
It was not just Welker's colleagues who were positive about her performance. American author Brigitte Gabriel said she did a better job than Wallace, and one person went so far as to suggest she deserved a medal for her performance.
And despite calling Welker "terrible and unfair" ahead of time, Trump took time during the debate to praise the moderator's performance.
"By the way, so far I respect very much the way you're handling this," he said.