Would a universal basic income make us lazy or creative?
Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Splash
  • Features
  • Videos
  • Long Read
  • Games
  • Epaper
  • More
    • COVID-19
    • Bangladesh
    • Infograph
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Thoughts
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Subscribe
    • Archive
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
    • Supplement
  • বাংলা
The Business Standard
FRIDAY, MAY 20, 2022
FRIDAY, MAY 20, 2022
  • Home
  • Economy
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Splash
  • Features
  • Videos
  • Long Read
  • Games
  • Epaper
  • More
    • COVID-19
    • Bangladesh
    • Infograph
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Thoughts
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Subscribe
    • Archive
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
    • Supplement
  • বাংলা
Would a universal basic income make us lazy or creative?

Analysis

Andreas Kluth, Bloomberg
05 October, 2020, 05:00 pm
Last modified: 05 October, 2020, 05:09 pm

Related News

  • The secret to creative breakthroughs, hot streaks and success
  • Will new Mexico prove a universal basic income can work?
  • Man collects 150 tonnes of garbage in 10yrs for ‘lazy’ son’s future
  • Procrastination: One thing I do every day
  • Disney, Warner Bros, Universal halts LA series amid covid-19 surge

Would a universal basic income make us lazy or creative?

Andreas Kluth, Bloomberg
05 October, 2020, 05:00 pm
Last modified: 05 October, 2020, 05:09 pm
They’re pro-UBI, but will it work? Photographer: Alex Wong/Getty Images North America/Bloomberg
They’re pro-UBI, but will it work? Photographer: Alex Wong/Getty Images North America/Bloomberg

To make good policy you should have at least a vague notion of what you're talking about. But when it comes to perhaps the biggest reform proposal around, we just don't. I'm talking about a Universal Basic Income, a system of unconditional cash payments to everybody in a given jurisdiction.

The case for a UBI runs as follows: It would reduce poverty, make people healthier and give them more dignity. It would also ease the transition of workers who lose their jobs to robots or artificial intelligence, so they can retrain for different careers. In general, it lets people bridge periods out of work or in bad jobs so they can invest in their own skills and reenter the workforce at a higher level.

To get out of a dead-end job, say, they might take a "sabbatical" for adult education. Or they could temporarily contribute in other valuable ways, for instance by homeschooling their children or caring for elderly parents. Moreover, because a UBI would replace most or (as I would like) all legacy welfare systems, its cost needn't be prohibitive.

Now the case against a UBI: It would devalue work as such and reward sloth. Without an existential need to work, why bother? A UBI would create a new and permanently dependent underclass, a lumpenproletariat of the Fourth Industrial Revolution. And to provide the nectar that feeds these UBI drones, all those diligent worker bees who still have jobs would have to pay unacceptably high taxes.

This clash between clichés is what the debate has deteriorated to. But how, in fact, would most human beings respond to "free" money? We haven't the faintest idea.

Lots of people have tried to find out, of course. Starting with Canada in the 1970s, various local, regional and national governments around the world have run experiments. So far, however, these haven't yielded much useful information. Sometimes a new government took office and halted a research project or changed its parameters beyond recognition. Or the study was designed poorly.

UBI geeks were particularly disappointed that a Finnish project that began in 2017 was first changed, then stopped after only two years. It, too, wasn't very well thought out — 2,000 Finns who were initially unemployed received a modest 560 euro ($654) a month and were compared against another group who continued to receive means-tested unemployment benefits.

To see the macroeconomic effect of a UBI, of course, you want to test it on a representative slice of the whole population, not just the jobless. Nonetheless, as imperfect as the Finnish study was, it did debunk one assumption of UBI opponents. Getting unconditional payouts not only increased the well-being of the participating Finns but also made them slightly more likely to find jobs. In short, they got healthier but not lazier.

Now there's excitement about another research project getting started in Germany. It might finally get the parameters right. Almost 2 million people from all walks of life have already applied to be guinea pigs. Starting in November, social scientists will select two groups. One, consisting of 120 people, will get 1,200 euros a month, starting next spring and lasting three years. They'll be compared against a control group of 1,380 who will be monitored but won't get any cash.

The twist in this experiment is that the organizers will look for "statistical twins." So if among the 120 there's a 25-year-old pianist who lives in an urban metropolis, has 5 years of higher education and good health, she'll have a doppelganger in the control group. So will the 40-year-old plumber from the countryside, the gig worker delivering Amazon packages, and so on.

By comparing these statistical twins over several years, says Juergen Schupp, the sociologist who leads the project, it should be possible to single out just the effects of the payments on people's lives. Eventually, they'll even compare hair samples for clues about stress hormones. As usual in science, the results won't necessarily prove a positive — that a UBI turns us into entrepreneurs, for example. But they should be able to falsify bad arguments — that a UBI makes us lazy, perhaps.

Even this project, of course, won't try to answer every question. Which existing welfare services would a UBI replace? Would it extend even to migrants and temporary residents? How would it be financed?

But it's a step in the right direction, and a reminder that policymakers in poor and rich countries alike need to keep an open mind. We are indeed in the midst of a digital transformation that will destroy many old jobs and create many new ones, and we need structures that help people adapt.

And, as the year 2020 reminded us all, every now and then something like a pandemic-induced recession comes along, against which a UBI just might be an ideal policy tool. It would certainly help if we could answer some of the big questions.


Andreas Kluth is a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion. He was previously editor in chief of Handelsblatt Global and a writer for the Economist. He's the author of "Hannibal and Me."

Disclaimer: This article first appeared on bloomberg.com, and is published by special syndication arrangement.

Top News

Universal / basic income / lazy / creative

Comments

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderation decisions are subjective. Published comments are readers’ own views and The Business Standard does not endorse any of the readers’ comments.

Top Stories

  • Students suffer over costlier food at public university canteens
    Students suffer over costlier food at public university canteens
  • A worker displays grains of wheat at a mill in Beirut, Lebanon, March 1, 2022. REUTERS/Mohamed Azakir/File Photo
    Russia can offer 25 mln tonnes of grain for export starting on 1 Aug: UN envoy
  • A model of the natural gas pipeline is seen in front of displayed Finnish and Russian flag colours in this illustration taken April 26, 2022. REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration
    Russian gas flows to Finland to stop on Saturday, says Gasum

MOST VIEWED

  • A green economic transition must not affect the wellbeing of the over 4 million RMG workers. Picture: MumitM/TBS
    Just Transition in an unjust world
  • Illustration: TBS
    Money supply needs to be curtailed to suppress domestic demand
  • Safety net needs to be expanded by minimising corruption 
    Safety net needs to be expanded by minimising corruption 
  • Domestic production should be boosted to meet aggregate demand
    Domestic production should be boosted to meet aggregate demand
  • File photo of Dr Debapriya Bhattacharya. Picture: CPD
    Fiscal consolidation is a way out
  • Falling trade barriers and hyper-efficient logistics produced an age of abundance for many. But the last four years have brought an escalating series of disruptions.Source: Bloomberg
    Age of scarcity begins with $1.6 trillion hit to world economy

Related News

  • The secret to creative breakthroughs, hot streaks and success
  • Will new Mexico prove a universal basic income can work?
  • Man collects 150 tonnes of garbage in 10yrs for ‘lazy’ son’s future
  • Procrastination: One thing I do every day
  • Disney, Warner Bros, Universal halts LA series amid covid-19 surge

Features

Mohammad (Mejbah) Mejbahuddin, Former Senior Secretary, Economic Relations Division (ERD), Ministry of Finance, Government of Bangladesh. TBS Sketch

‘No project is being delayed too long at the moment’

2h | Panorama
Dr Shamsul Hoque, Professor, Civil Engineering, BUET. TBS Sketch

‘Planning commission only in the name, there are no planners’ 

2h | Panorama
Masrur Reaz. TBS Sketch

‘To ensure accountability, contract financing should be based on ‘performance based payments’

2h | Panorama
Professor Mustafizur Rahman. Illustration: TBS

Project delays and escalating costs are driven by frequent revisions and lack of good governance

5h | Panorama

More Videos from TBS

Ways to retain body fragrance

Ways to retain body fragrance

3h | Videos
Gazipur restaurant that serves 150 food items

Gazipur restaurant that serves 150 food items

7h | Videos
How to prepare for a job

How to prepare for a job

8h | Videos
Putin's strategies to face Nato

Putin's strategies to face Nato

19h | Videos

Most Read

1
Tk100 for bike, Tk2,400 for bus to cross Padma Bridge
Bangladesh

Tk100 for bike, Tk2,400 for bus to cross Padma Bridge

2
Representative Photo: Pixabay.
Bangladesh

Microplastics found in 5 local sugar brands

3
Mushfiq Mobarak. Photo: Noor-A-Alam
Panorama

Meet the Yale professor who anchors his research in Bangladesh and scales up interventions globally

4
A packet of US five-dollar bills is inspected at the Bureau of Engraving and Printing in Washington March 26, 2015. REUTERS/Gary Cameron
Banking

Dollar hits Tk100 mark in open market

5
The story of Bangladesh becoming a major bicycle exporter
Industry

The story of Bangladesh becoming a major bicycle exporter

6
PK Halder: How a scamster rose from humble beginnings to a Tk11,000cr empire
Crime

PK Halder: How a scamster rose from humble beginnings to a Tk11,000cr empire

The Business Standard
Top
  • Home
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • About Us
  • Bangladesh
  • International
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Economy
  • Sitemap
  • RSS

Contact Us

The Business Standard

Main Office -4/A, Eskaton Garden, Dhaka- 1000

Phone: +8801847 416158 - 59

Send Opinion articles to - oped.tbs@gmail.com

For advertisement- sales@tbsnews.net

Copyright © 2022 THE BUSINESS STANDARD All rights reserved. Technical Partner: RSI Lab