This Nobel-winning idea has failed India
Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Economy
    • Aviation
    • Bazaar
    • Budget
    • Industry
    • NBR
    • RMG
    • Corporates
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Book Review
    • Brands
    • Earth
    • Explorer
    • Fact Check
    • Family
    • Food
    • Game Reviews
    • Good Practices
    • Habitat
    • Humour
    • In Focus
    • Luxury
    • Mode
    • Panorama
    • Pursuit
    • Wealth
    • Wellbeing
    • Wheels
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Videos
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • COVID-19
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
  • বাংলা
The Business Standard

Friday
January 27, 2023

Sign In
Subscribe
  • Home
  • Economy
    • Aviation
    • Bazaar
    • Budget
    • Industry
    • NBR
    • RMG
    • Corporates
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Book Review
    • Brands
    • Earth
    • Explorer
    • Fact Check
    • Family
    • Food
    • Game Reviews
    • Good Practices
    • Habitat
    • Humour
    • In Focus
    • Luxury
    • Mode
    • Panorama
    • Pursuit
    • Wealth
    • Wellbeing
    • Wheels
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Videos
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • COVID-19
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
  • বাংলা
FRIDAY, JANUARY 27, 2023
This Nobel-winning idea has failed India

Analysis

Mihir Sharma, Bloomberg
14 October, 2020, 04:30 pm
Last modified: 14 October, 2020, 05:36 pm

Related News

  • ‘Intransigence’: India notifies Pakistan of plans to amend Indus Waters Treaty
  • India expects more clashes with Chinese troops in Himalayas
  • India aims high as hydrogen power alternatives get boost
  • India launches world’s 1st intranasal Covid vaccine
  • 'Pathaan' release sees scattered protests across India

This Nobel-winning idea has failed India

The auctions pioneered by this year’s economics laureates have backfired badly in some emerging markets

Mihir Sharma, Bloomberg
14 October, 2020, 04:30 pm
Last modified: 14 October, 2020, 05:36 pm
India’s telecom revolution only took off after the government shifted away from auctioning spectrum.  Photographer: Arun Sankar/AFP/Getty Images
India’s telecom revolution only took off after the government shifted away from auctioning spectrum. Photographer: Arun Sankar/AFP/Getty Images

Economists like to think of themselves as mathematicians — or, if feeling momentarily humbler, as physicists. This year's winners of the Nobel Prize in economics, however, seem to conceive of themselves more as engineers. Like Alvin Roth and Lloyd Shapley, who won the prize in 2012, Paul Milgrom and Robert B Wilson are specialists in "market design," a field which, as Roth wrote in a famous paper, calls for "an engineering approach."

Roth argued that market designers should take bridge-builders as their exemplars: "Engineering is often less elegant than the simple underlying physics, but it allows bridges designed on the same basic model to be built longer and stronger over time, as the complexities and how to deal with them become better understood."

The bridge that Milgrom and Wilson built was the 1994 auction of telecommunications spectrum by the Federal Communications Commission, later called "the greatest auction in history." In its 50th anniversary volume, the National Science Foundation used the $7 billion in revenue the auction generated as a justification for its years of support of game theorists. Since then, auctions have become the gold standard for the distribution of all sorts of natural resources, from exploration permits to mining leases to railway franchises. It is almost taken for granted that, if properly designed, auctions will find the ideal balance between efficiency and revenue generation.

But, it turns out, economists don't actually work like engineers. The example set by the FCC auction has in many ways turned out to be very unhelpful, particularly in emerging markets.

There are lots of reasons for this. One is built into the notion of auction design itself. In much of the early academic literature on auctions, economists tried to maximize the sum of state revenue and consumer surplus. But setting goals is the task of regulators and politicians, not economists.

Policy makers may have multiple other considerations, complicating market design considerably. South Africa had three failed auctions between 2010 and 2017, for instance, because regulators sought to design them to further the government's broader economic inclusion agenda. To general amusement, the government announced last month that it was trying again.

It's even worse when countries try to maximize just one variable, because for bureaucrats and politicians that variable is usually government revenue. Economists generally don't object because revenue is easier to measure than consumer utility, making their job simpler. In India, for example, the government has grown addicted to using telecom spectrum revenue to help finance its deficits.

But the more a company pays for spectrum, the lower its profits and the less it has left to invest in new infrastructure. In India, high fees have led to high levels of debt. Constant demands from the government for cash have caused telecom providers to look for the exit. And spectrum scarcity leads to low quality service: In 2019, India had 50 times as many subscribers per MHz of spectrum as did Germany.

Indians at least should have known this would happen. The country's telecom revolution — which drove its years of high growth in the 2000s — only took off after the government moved away from auctions and started assigning spectrum to licensees in return for a share of their revenue.

Worse, for those who imagine that auctions designed to maximize government revenue would at least maximize government revenue: The new system brought in twice as much in fees as the auction bids would have.

And suppose that, in order to ensure government revenue was robust, auctions set their reserve price too high, as has happened in Ghana and Bangladesh? Would consumers be served well by a poor-quality oligopoly or even a monopoly? Would that benefit the broader economy? Can Milgrom, Wilson or their successors design an auction model that takes into account the effect on overall economic growth of vibrant and cutting-edge telecom infrastructure? Maybe they can. All I can say for certain is nobody has.

That doesn't mean they should not try. This is a well-deserved Nobel prize not because the bridge these economists built can be erected over any kind of river, but because it got built in the first place. The true miracle was the transparent, inclusive, academically informed process that led to its design. It ensured that the specific complexities of that market at that time were clearly reflected in the eventual auction design.

Market designers can't give up because they haven't been able to replicate that Nobel-worthy success. They need to work harder and think bigger.


Mihir Sharma is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist.


Disclaimer: This opinion first appeared on Bloomberg, and is published by special syndication arrangement


 

Top News / World+Biz / South Asia

India / Economists

Comments

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderation decisions are subjective. Published comments are readers’ own views and The Business Standard does not endorse any of the readers’ comments.

Top Stories

  • Photo: Bloomberg
    India's Adani slammed by $48 bln stock rout, clouding record share sale
  • Infograph: TBS
    State banks spend 80% of their forex for govt imports in H1
  • Global central banks preaching on pay are enforcing squeeze too
    Global central banks preaching on pay are enforcing squeeze too

MOST VIEWED

  • Illustration: TBS
    HC verdict moves the needle on recognising single motherhood
  • Illustration: Jinhwa Jang for Bloomberg Businessweek
    Is a US recession near? Making the call is trickier than ever
  •  Gautam Adani, center.Photographer: Tomohiro Ohsumi/Bloomberg
    The Adani short sale puts investor trust in India in doubt
  • Dominion Energy is seeking to extend the operating license of its North Anna Nuclear Generating Station located in Louisa County, Va., to 80 years. Photographer: Scott Olson/Getty Images North America
    Nuclear power plants are pushed to the limit as demand surges
  • Photo: Bloomberg
    The worst fears for global growth may be subsiding
  • An island unto themselves.Photographer: Sam Yeh/AFP
    US could defend Taiwan from China - at great cost

Related News

  • ‘Intransigence’: India notifies Pakistan of plans to amend Indus Waters Treaty
  • India expects more clashes with Chinese troops in Himalayas
  • India aims high as hydrogen power alternatives get boost
  • India launches world’s 1st intranasal Covid vaccine
  • 'Pathaan' release sees scattered protests across India

Features

Sketch:TBS

Why we need consumer education for consumer wellbeing

8h | Thoughts
Dr Ahsan H Mansur, Executive Director, Policy Research Institute. Illustration: TBS

Twin shocks call for stronger domestic policy response

9h | Thoughts
December-er shohor, taxi taken for airport and the Park Street bathed in lights. Photo: Jannatul Naym Pieal

Exploring Kolkata on foot, empowered by Google Maps

10h | Explorer
Island hopping in Bangladesh?

Island hopping in Bangladesh?

11h | Panorama

More Videos from TBS

Kajol’s road paintings bring change in Gafargaon

Kajol’s road paintings bring change in Gafargaon

1d | TBS Stories
Carew & Company witnessed a remarkable growth

Carew & Company witnessed a remarkable growth

1d | TBS Stories
After all the controversies, how is Shah Rukh Khan's ‘Pathaan’?

After all the controversies, how is Shah Rukh Khan's ‘Pathaan’?

1h | TBS Entertainment
PCB recalls cricketers from BPL ahead of PSL

PCB recalls cricketers from BPL ahead of PSL

1d | TBS SPORTS

Most Read

1
Picture: Collected
Bangladesh

US Embassy condemns recent incidents of visa fraud

2
Four top bankers arrested in DSA case filed by S Alam group 
Bangladesh

Four top bankers arrested in DSA case filed by S Alam group 

3
Illustration: TBS
Banking

16 banks at risk of capital shortfall if top 3 borrowers default

4
Photo: Collected
Splash

Hansal Mehta responds as Twitter user calls him 'shameless' for making Faraaz

5
A frozen Beyond Burger plant-based patty. Photographer: AKIRA for Bloomberg Businessweek
Bloomberg Special

Fake meat was supposed to save the world. It became just another fad

6
Representational Image
Banking

Cash-strapped Islami, Al-Arafah and National turn to Sonali Bank for costly fund

EMAIL US
[email protected]
FOLLOW US
WHATSAPP
+880 1847416158
The Business Standard
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
Copyright © 2023
The Business Standard All rights reserved
Technical Partner: RSI Lab

Contact Us

The Business Standard

Main Office -4/A, Eskaton Garden, Dhaka- 1000

Phone: +8801847 416158 - 59

Send Opinion articles to - [email protected]

For advertisement- [email protected]